| Business | Phone |
| Haldimand Insurance Brokers 5 Caithness St W, Caledonia N3W 1B7 | (905) 765-2661 |
| State Farm Insurance Co 225 Argyle St N, Caledonia N3W 1K9 | (905) 765-1100 |
| Cayuga Mutual Fire Insurance 172 Argyle St N, Caledonia N3W 2J7 | (905) 765-5498 |
| Co-Operators 345 Argyle St S, Caledonia N3W 1L8 | (905) 765-5788 |