| Business | Phone |
| Arrenellos Pizza Inc 2556 45th St, Highland 46322 | (219) 924-2525 |
| Barton's Pizzeria 3925 45th St, Highland 46322 | (219) 924-6200 |
| Cholie's Pizza 8020 Kennedy Ave, Highland 46322 | (219) 838-8600 |
| Jo Jo' S Pizza 2712 Condit St, Highland 46322 | (219) 838-6330 |
| Langel's Pizza 2833 Highway Ave, Highland 46322 | (219) 923-4900 |
| Ricciardi Ristorante Pizza 9400 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland 46322 | (219) 922-9999 |
| Sanfratello's Pizza 2100 45th St, Highland 46322 | (219) 922-1400 |
| Squigi's Pizza Of Highland 8327 Kennedy Ave, Highland 46322 | (219) 838-4600 |
| State Line Pizza 9521 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland 46322 | (219) 924-9227 |
| Zuni's Pizza 2907 45th St, Highland 46322 | (219) 924-8888 |