| Business | Phone |
| Community Christian Church 201 W Michigan St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-3344 |
| Hudson Lake Church Of Christ 8426 E Ivy Blvd, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-7651 |
| Hudson Lake Mennonite Church 7503 N Walker Rd, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-8388 |
| Maple Grove United Methodist 6655 E 1000 N, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-7886 |
| New Carlisle Wesleyan Church 32645 Early Rd, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-7898 |
| New Prairie Christian Fellow Po Box 838, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-8910 |
| New Prarie Christian Fellowshp 31519 Chicago Trl, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-8492 |
| Olive Chapel Congregational Ch 32987 State Road 2, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-3615 |
| Prairie Gardens Christian 29301 Lynn St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-3459 |
| Prairie Gardens Christian Chr 107 E Michigan St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-8410 |
| Prairie Gardens Church Office 29301 Lynn St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-8410 |
| St Stanislaus Kostka Catholic 55756 Tulip Rd, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-3781 |
| United Methodist Church 300 Compton St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-7442 |
| Wesleyan Church 201 Ada St, New Carlisle 46552 | (574) 654-3915 |