| Business | Phone |
| Aflac 200 N 12th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-8992 |
| Allstate Insurance 1824 Bundy Ave, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-0707 |
| Ameriana Insurance Agency Inc 1908 Bundy Ave, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-5049 |
| American Family Insurance 520 S Main St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-4441 |
| Associated Agencies Insurance 1700 S Memorial Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-3030 |
| Baker Insurance 536 N Memorial Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 521-4181 |
| Baldock Hayes Insurance Svc 200 N 12th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-8993 |
| Bruce Winningham Insurance 301 S 17th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-9722 |
| Chapin-Hayworth Insurance 201 N 12th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-0002 |
| Clemens Insurance & Financial 1202 Vine St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-5420 |
| Cronk-Mc Craine Insurance 819 Broad St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 521-9682 |
| Farm Bureau Insurance 151a Wittenbreaker Ave, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-1000 |
| Firemark Insurance 703 Broad St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-0336 |
| Koontz & Lewis Inc 309 Parkview Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 521-0818 |
| Koontz Insurance & Financial 309 Parkview Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 521-4530 |
| Lewis Insurance 311 Parkview Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 521-6070 |
| Petty Insurance 702 Broad St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-5744 |
| Pfenninger Insurance Inc 1220 Broad St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-6400 |
| Primerica Financial Svc 700 S Memorial Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 593-0327 |
| Shelter Insurance 1817 S Memorial Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-0185 |
| Star Insurance 403 Parkview Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 593-5130 |
| State Farm Insurance 210 S Main St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-2751 |
| State Farm Insurance 3130 S 14th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-7010 |
| State Farm Insurance 318 Parkview Dr, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-8755 |
| Ted Norris Insurance 2303 S 14th St, New Castle 47362 | (765) 529-7403 |