| Business | Phone |
| American Family Insurance 116 E Lafayette St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-2405 |
| B & S Insurance 118 E Lafayette St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-2086 |
| Carl Webber Agency 205 S Main St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-2033 |
| Farm Bureau Insurance 311 S Dickerson St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-4719 |
| Farmers Mutual Insurance Co 621 S Main St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-4615 |
| Insurance Services Inc 305 S Main St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-4311 |
| John M Buckman Insurance 123 S Main St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-6161 |
| Larry Dudgeon Insurance 308 S Main St # B, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-3660 |
| State Farm Insurance 211 S Main St, Palmyra 63461 | (573) 769-3330 |