| Business | Phone |
| Arnett Wise Insurance 126 Shelby Plaza Rd, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-4200 |
| Shelter Insurance 111 S Center St, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-2185 |
| Mike Fohey Insurance Inc 300 N Center St, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-4565 |
| Hawkins Insurance Group 119 E Walnut St, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-2125 |
| Farm Bureau Insurance 200 E Chestnut St, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-4196 |
| Farmers Mutual Fire Ins Co 106 E Chestnut St, Shelbina 63468 | (573) 588-7648 |