| Business | Phone |
| Allegany Baptist Church 3236 Maple Ave, Allegany 14706 | (716) 372-9029 |
| Allegany Full Gospel Church 50 N 3rd St, Allegany 14706 | (716) 372-3069 |
| Church Of God Of Prophecy 71 W Main St, Allegany 14706 | (716) 373-7371 |
| First Free Methodist Church 2523 Five Mile Rd, Allegany 14706 | (716) 372-0388 |
| First Presbyterian Church 44 N 3rd St, Allegany 14706 | (716) 372-2912 |
| Five Mile Baptist Church 3624 Five Mile Rd, Allegany 14706 | (716) 373-1832 |
| St Bonaventure Parish 95 E Main St, Allegany 14706 | (716) 373-1330 |
| St John's Lutheran Church 36 N 4th St, Allegany 14706 | (716) 373-0025 |