| Business | Phone |
| Lighthouse Tabernacle Church 1057 Cassel Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 234-2355 |
| Living Proof Church Of God 105 2nd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-9451 |
| Assembly Of Christian Churches 476 Candlewood Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 231-7961 |
| Love & Mercy Fellowship 1420 Union Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 969-7968 |
| Bay Shore Church-The Nazarene 1314 Pine Acres Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 969-1730 |
| Calvary Baptist Church 1040 Union Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-8367 |
| Calvary Tabernacle Chr Of God 6 Holbrook St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-4422 |
| Christian Science Churches 8 Lawrence Ln, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-0923 |
| Christian Science Reading Rm 296 W Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-0923 |
| Church Of Jesus Christ Of Lds 351 Brook Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 969-9425 |
| Ebenezer Christian Church 69 Wisconsin Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 273-6912 |
| Emanuel Assembly Of God 125 2nd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-9238 |
| First Baptist Church 175 2nd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-8863 |
| First Congregational Church 1860 Union Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-0091 |
| First Spanish Baptist Church 1568 5th Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-9567 |
| First United American 160 Howells Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 206-0570 |
| Gospel Lighthouse Pentecostal 51 Brook St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-5919 |
| Gospel Lighthouse Pentecostal 88 2nd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-2588 |
| Pentecostal Christian Church 61 Pine Aire Dr, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 435-8976 |
| Heritage Baptist Church 1380 5th Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-5358 |
| Iglesia Bautista Fundamental 33 Connecticut Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-2457 |
| Iglesia Evangelica Apostoles 1650 E 3rd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 951-4075 |
| Iglesia Pentecostal Aog 814 Nassau Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 436-7975 |
| Iglesia Pentecostal Refugio 66 Candlewood Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 436-7975 |
| Iglesia Pentecostal Regugio 5 Fairtown Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 436-5276 |
| Jehovahs Witnesses Hall 1647 Heckscher Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-8768 |
| Jesus Outreach Deliverance 6 Ackerson St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-1337 |
| Judah Apostolic Church 9 Pembrooke Ct, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 206-0093 |
| St Lukes Lutheran Church 3 Lawrence Ln, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-2554 |
| St Patrick's Rc Church 9 N Clinton Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-4911 |
| St Patricks Rc Church Of 6 5th Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-5046 |
| St Peter's Episcopal Church 500 S Country Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-0051 |
| United Methodist Church 107 E Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-7194 |
| Unity Greater Highway Church 3 2nd Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-6415 |
| Uu Society Of South Suffolk 28 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-0667 |