| Business | Phone |
| Amore Pizzeria 2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-8181 |
| Bono's Pizza Of Bay Shore 1397 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-1151 |
| Bruno's Pizzeria & Restorante 1556 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 968-5588 |
| Buseto Pizza 1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-4939 |
| Carolina Pizza Restaurant Inc 275 W Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-4400 |
| De Natalie Pizzeria & Restaurant 222 5th Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-6388 |
| Domino's Pizza 1765 Union Blvd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 206-0300 |
| Fratelli Pizzeria 553 E Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-0458 |
| Papa John's Pizza 1 Railroad Plz, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 969-2300 |
| Gino's Pizzeria 45 W Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-6350 |
| Paul's Pizza 3 W Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 254-4240 |
| Pizza Inc 1585 5th Ave, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 666-2034 |
| Jerry's Pizza 1639 5th Ave # 4, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 951-2020 |
| Joe's Pizza 73 Howells Rd, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-2524 |
| Sbarro 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 969-0809 |
| Tina's Pizza Ii 635 E Main St, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-1010 |
| Victorio's Pizza 1205 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore 11706 | (631) 665-3193 |