| Business | Phone |
| Aversano's Restaurant & Pizza 1620 Route 22, Brewster 10509 | (845) 279-2233 |
| Brewster Square Pizza 107 Brewster Sq, Brewster 10509 | (845) 278-4500 |
| Ii Brothers Pizza 3867 Route 6, Brewster 10509 | (845) 278-9754 |
| Pizza Place 70 Main St, Brewster 10509 | (845) 279-5944 |
| Sinapi Pizzeria 21 Stebbins Farm Rd, Brewster 10509 | (845) 278-9632 |
| Sinapi Pizzeria Route 22, Brewster 10509 | (845) 278-9632 |
| Zegarelli's Pizza 110 Fairfield Dr, Brewster 10509 | (845) 278-7174 |