| Business | Phone |
| Brother Bruno Pizza Restaurant Route 42 N, Monticello 12701 | (845) 791-4600 |
| Colossio Pizza Restaurant 11 Raceway Rd, Monticello 12701 | (845) 791-1255 |
| Kosher Pizza Palace 66 Broadway, Monticello 12701 | (845) 794-3420 |
| Mama Toma's Pizzeria 334 Broadway, Monticello 12701 | (845) 791-5250 |
| Pizza Hut 140 Broadway, Monticello 12701 | (845) 796-1616 |
| Roma Pizza Restaurant 121 Broadway, Monticello 12701 | (845) 791-7662 |
| Valley Pizzeria 40 Kitz Rd, Monticello 12701 | (845) 794-5150 |