| Business | Phone |
| Benton Methodist Church 2395 Havens Corners Rd, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-9819 |
| Church Of Jesus Christ Of Lds Penn Yan Branch Flat, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-5635 |
| Dresden United Methodist Chr 58 Cornelia, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-9351 |
| First Baptist Church 224 Main St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-9821 |
| First Presbyterian Church 211 Main St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-8235 |
| Friend United Methodist Church 4188 Friend Rd, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-5443 |
| Kingdom Hall-Jehovah's Witness 1600 Route 54, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-8971 |
| Milo Center Methodist Church 1421 Milo Center Rd, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 531-9218 |
| Nazarene Church Brown Street Ext, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-9357 |
| Penn Yan Assembly Of God 1952 Gibbs Rd, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 531-1902 |
| Penn Yan Bible Church 2015 Kimball Rd, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-4523 |
| Penn Yan United Methodist Chur 166 Main St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-6711 |
| St Mark's Episcopal Church 179 Main St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-3955 |
| St Michael's Catholic Church 210 Keuka St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-7459 |
| St Paul Lutheran Church 135 Hamilton St, Penn Yan 14527 | (315) 536-8165 |