| Business | Phone |
| Domino's Pizza 520 West St, Caldwell 43724 | (740) 732-0732 |
| East Of Chicago Pizza Co 515 West St, Caldwell 43724 | (740) 732-8800 |
| Geri's Pizza 44475 State Route 821, Caldwell 43724 | (740) 732-2496 |
| Plus One Pizza Olive Rd, Caldwell 43724 | (740) 732-5221 |
| Wally's Old Fashioned Pizza 805 Miller St, Caldwell 43724 | (740) 732-4241 |