| Business | Phone |
| Church Honey Creek Christian 11325 Ayres Pike, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 857-0108 |
| Church Of Christ 6170 Scarff Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 846-0923 |
| Church Of The Brethren 219 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1428 |
| Colonial Baptist Church 8963 Milton Carlisle Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 882-6903 |
| Crossroad Baptist Church 9903 W National Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-9866 |
| First Baptist Church 8870 E State Route 571, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1211 |
| First United Methodist Church 110 E Madison St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-2236 |
| First United Methodist Church 220 S Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-8435 |
| Gethsemane Brethren In Christ 7045 E State Route 40, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-8895 |
| Good Shepherd Methodist Church 1520 Styer Dr, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-0697 |
| Grace Fellowship Church 85 Quick Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-5909 |
| Honey Creek Presbyterian 212 W Jefferson St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1298 |
| Huber Mennonite Church 1885 S Dayton Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-6720 |
| Lake Avenue Christian Church 1101 W Lake Ave, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1131 |
| Miami Valley United Bptst Chr 660 Hyde Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 231-0422 |
| Missionary Church 111 N Adams St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1460 |
| Missionary Church 221 Zimmerman St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1460 |
| New Carlisle Church Of Christ 235 Funston Ave, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-8467 |
| New Carlisle Church-Nazarene 477 N Scott St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-9990 |
| New Carlisle First Freewill Ch 9555 New Carlisle Pike, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-9567 |
| New Carlisle Seventh-Day Chr 501 S Dayton Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-9902 |
| New Hope Church Of God 595 N Medway Carlisle Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-4205 |
| Park Layne Baptist Church 9045 Bellefontaine Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (513) 849-0911 |
| Park Layne First Church-God 8692 Bellefontaine Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-9795 |
| Park Layne United Brethren 1320 Styer Dr, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-0611 |
| Sacred Heart Church 476 N Scott St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-3121 |
| St Mark's Lutheran Church 200 E Lake Ave, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0011 |