| Business | Phone |
| American Family Insurance 105 S Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 846-0793 |
| First Group 309 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0138 |
| Grimone Insurance 133 S Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0889 |
| Grimone Insurance & Financial 412 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0889 |
| J & R Insurance 100 S Church St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-8436 |
| Mc Glothin Insurance 216 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0004 |
| Milliken-Williams Insurance 128 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-3596 |
| State Farm Insurance 325 S Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0127 |