| Business | Phone |
| Cassano's Pizza King 1525 S Dayton Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-9051 |
| Domino's Pizza 331 S Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-0202 |
| Lyons' Pizza Carry Out 5 Jeffrey Ln, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 846-1700 |
| Papa John's Pizza 410 N Main St, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 846-1155 |
| Park Layne Pizza & Sports 2015 S Dayton Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 849-1112 |
| Pizza Plus Inc 101 Galewood Dr, New Carlisle 45344 | (937) 845-1005 |