| Business | Phone |
| American Family Insurance 126 E Broadway St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-3999 |
| Farmers Insurance Group 116 W Jefferson St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-7620 |
| Ogden Insurance Inc 123 S Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-3163 |
| Sawyers Insurance 200 S Jackson St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-0100 |
| State Farm Insurance 233 W Broadway St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-3348 |
| Thompson Insurance 102 S Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-1986 |
| Western-Southern Life Ins Co 117 N Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-2414 |