| Business | Phone |
| Creno's Pizza 787 Carroll St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 343-0405 |
| Domino's Pizza 122 N Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-5141 |
| Gold Mine Pizza 400 S State St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-1111 |
| New Pizzeria 531 S Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-4988 |
| Panther Drive In 600 S Main St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-3314 |
| Pizza Hut 512 Carroll St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-2525 |
| Pizza Place & Restaurant 100 W Broadway St, New Lexington 43764 | (740) 342-5123 |