| Business | Phone |
| Center Valley Baptist Church 75 Mcmahan Rd, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 473-2521 |
| Christian Union Chr Parsonage 33488 State Route 26, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 934-9539 |
| Church Gravel Hill Baptist 33125 State Route 800, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-3801 |
| First Baptist Church 400 Broadway Wave, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-2167 |
| Gravel Hill Baptist Church State Route 800, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-3067 |
| Harmony Hill Baptist Church 41051 Trail Run Rd, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-3835 |
| Harvest Time Church Of God 1015 Park Ave, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-9903 |
| New Hope Full Gospel Church 3560 East Pke, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 455-9775 |
| New Matamoras Church-Nazarene 502 Front St, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-3981 |
| New Matamoras United Methodist 602 3rd St, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-2415 |
| St Paul's Church Trail Run Rd, New Matamoras 45767 | (740) 865-3589 |