| Business | Phone |
| Zion Lutheran Church 10857 Main St, New Middletown 44442 | (330) 542-3821 |
| Bethel Church Of The Brethren 4023 E Calla Rd, New Middletown 44442 | (330) 542-3750 |
| Free Methodist Community Chr 9900 Youngstown Pittsburgh Rd, New Middletown 44442 | (330) 542-3732 |
| St Paul The Apostle Catholic 10143 Main St, New Middletown 44442 | (330) 542-3525 |