| Business | Phone |
| Bakersville Presbyterian Chr 28164 County Road 97, Newcomerstown 43832 | (330) 897-2420 |
| Birds Run Community Church 73007 Hopewell Rd, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-7564 |
| Calvary United Methodist Chr W State & Heller Dramp;, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-8766 |
| Christ United Methodist Church 648 Oak St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-8134 |
| Church Of Christ 475 S Goodrich St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6442 |
| Church Of Christ In Christian 560 W State St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-7631 |
| Church Of The Nazarene 363 Neighbor St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-7588 |
| Cornerstone North Full Gospel 1124 W State St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-5662 |
| First Baptist Church 135 S River St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6589 |
| First Baptist Church 214 W Main St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6284 |
| First Presbyterian Church 205 W Canal St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-8672 |
| Flat Ridge Church 17586 Carrol Rd, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-8154 |
| Foursquare Gospel Church 313 West St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6247 |
| Full Gospel Temple 15861 Kedigh Hollow Rd, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-7674 |
| St Francis Desales Church 440 S River St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-7368 |
| St Paul Lutheran Church 108 S River St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6682 |
| St Paul Lutheran Church 121 S College St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-6682 |
| Newcomerstown Church Of God 305 W Church St, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 492-1061 |
| Isleta United Methodist Church 58608 County Road 9, Newcomerstown 43832 | (740) 498-5425 |