| Business | Phone |
| First Baptist Church 207 Lafayette St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-2959 |
| First Church Of God 418 Brian Ln, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-2023 |
| First United Methodist Church 234 Penn St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-3900 |
| Grace Baptist Church Keck Ave, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-4090 |
| Jerusalem Lutheran Church Rr 1 Box 215, New Bethlehem 16242 | (724) 545-7114 |
| Kellersburg Ev Missionary Ch 121 King St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-1617 |
| Leatherwood Church 889 Church Rd, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-4371 |
| New Bethlehem Mennonite Church 805 Frosty Rd, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-3033 |
| New Bethlehem Presbyterian Chr 403 Penn St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-1880 |
| Oakdale Church Of The Brethren Rr 1 Box 49d, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-1888 |
| Oakwood Presbyterian Church 9296 Curllsville Rd, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-3242 |
| Putneyville Methodist Church Rr 1, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-4049 |
| South Bethlehem Boro Grant St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-4079 |
| Springside Baptist Church Rr 2, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-4953 |
| St Charles Church 201 Washington St, New Bethlehem 16242 | (814) 275-3446 |