27 December 2022

Armistice Day, 11th November 1918-2018.


Huge crowd at Parliament House for the Declaration of the Signing of the Armistice 
Adelaide, 1918
Photo credit: Australian War Memorial


By Nov 1918 the Allied armies had driven the German invaders back, having inflicted heavy defeats on them over the preceding months. Finally the Germans accepted Allied terms, signing an armistice in Commander Marshal Ferdinand Foch’s railway carriage, stationed in the Compiègne forest north of Paris.

When the formal Armistice came into effect on 11th Nov 1918, the guns of the Western Front fell silent for the first time in over four years of brutal warfare.

It was early morning in Britain when peace was declared, but grad­ually the news was spreading, on the western front and the home front. Soldiers were cheering after sunrise. Ports celebrated early because that was where people were given the news by the sirens of naval vessels. In London crowds formed in Downing St, as newspapers and newsboys spread the word. The prime minister David Lloyd George appeared outside #10 and received the cheers of many thousands of citizens. In many towns, bells & music announced the news. In churches every­where, the emphasis was on triumph, not remembrance of the dead.

When it got dark across Britain, fireworks and bonfires were lit, and street lights came on for the first time in years. It was a magical evening. Quiet didn’t arrive until midnight.

From then on, Armistice Day was marked on 11th hour of 11th day of 11th month each year. This first modern world conflict had brought about the mobilisation of 70+ million people and left 9-13 million dead, perhaps one-third of them with no known grave. The Allied nations chose this day and time for the commemoration of their war dead.

On the first anniversary of the armistice in 1919, 2 minutes' silence was used as part of the main commemorative ceremony at the new Cenotaph in London. The silence was proposed by Aust­ralian journalist Edward Honey, who was working in Fleet St. At the same time, a South African statesman made a similar proposal to the British Cabinet which endorsed it. King George V personally requested all British Empire peoples to sus­pend normal activities for two minutes on the hour of the armistice. After all, this was the moment that ended the worldwide carnage of the four preceding years and marked the victory of Right and Freedom. The two minutes' silence became the central feature of Armistice Day commemorations.

In the four years of WW1, 330,000+ Australians had served overseas and 60,000+ of them had died. The social effects of these losses cast a misery over families, communities and the nation in the 1919-39 era. 

Note Castlereagh St Sydney looking down to George St where a large crowd which had gathered in Martin Place to cel­ebrate Armistice Day’s first anniversary in 1919. The clock on the GPO building says 12 o'clock and a replica sailing ship float has been set up in the centre.

First anniversary of Armistice Day in Sydney, 1919
Photo credit: Australian War Memorial

On the second anniversary of the armistice in 1920 the commem­or­ation was given added significance when it became a funeral, with the return of the remains of an unknown soldier from the Western Front. Unknown soldiers were interred with full military honours in Westminster Abbey in London and at the Arc de Triumph in Paris. The entombment in London attracted 1,000,000+ people within a week to pay their respects at the unknown soldier's tomb. Most other allied nations adopted the tradition of entombing unknown soldiers over the following decade.

Charles Bean, Australia's official WWI historian, planned a museum memorial to Australian soldiers. The Australian War Records Sect­ion was established in May 1917, the records being exhibited first in Melbourne and later in the new Federal capital, Canberra. Two of the entrants in an architecture competition, Emil Sodersten and John Crust, were encouraged to present a joint design for the new Australian War Memorial in Canberra. The War Memorial building was officially opened following a Rem­em­br­ance Day cerem­ony on 11th Nov 1941 by Governor-General Lord Gowrie. Newer add­itions allowed the remembrance of Australia's particip­at­ion in all subsequent wars. 

After WW2 ended, the Australian & British governments changed the name from Armistice Day to Remembrance Day, to comm­emorate all war dead. All school students in the post-war era were assembled before 11 AM, to lower the flag to half mast and to honour the 2 minutes of silence. I remember it very well!

In Australia on the 75th anniversary of the armistice in 1993 Remembrance Day ceremonies again became the focus of national att­ent­ion. The remains of an unknown Australian soldier, exhumed from a WW1 military cemetery in France, were ceremonially entombed in the Memorial's Hall of Memory. Remembrance Day ceremonies were cond­uct­ed simultaneously in towns and cities all over the country. The day was formally re-established as a significant national day.

Remembrance Day 2018
Australian War Memorial, Canberra

On every Remembrance Day, the Australian War Memorial in Canberra hosts the nation’s key commemoration. The ceremony, which includes a formal wreath laying, is attended by many high-level dignitaries, diplomats, school students and members of the general public. Australia’s Federation Guard and the Band of the Royal Military College Duntroon form part of the parade.

What about ANZAC Day each year? 25th April marks the anniversary of the first major military action fought by Australian and New Zealand forces during WW1. Anzac Day carried proof of untested national qualities, with some imperial endorsement for the Australian and New Zealand fighting men. For most it was a day to proudly remember service and sacrifice. Thus Anzac Day combined mourning AND nation-building in a way that Remembrance Day did not; positivity amid the solemnity. Grief and national pride were combined in equal measure, meaning that Anzac Day was understood in different ways. For some it was a day to proudly remember service and sacrifice. For my grandfather and father, it was a day to remember the tragedy of war.

red poppies on the Roll of Honour
Australian War Memorial, Canberra





19 comments:

roentare said...

It is great to learn that piece of history that there is a difference between Armistice Day and ANZAC day

Joe said...

When I was a high school student, we had a memorial assembly every ANZAC day. Do students still participate in this sort of ceremony today?

David Watt said...

The first commemorative event of Anzac Day is the Dawn Service at 4.30 am. This is about the time men of the ANZAC approached the Gallipoli beach. The troops would be woken so that by the first rays of dawn they were in position and alert, in case of an enemy attack in the eerie half-light. It is a ritual and a moment remembered by many veterans.

Some debate exists about the first Dawn Service. Nevertheless, early dawn services were held in 1923 at Albany, Western Australia, conducted by the Reverend of St John’s Church, and formerly a padre with the 44th Battalion on the Western Front. The first official Dawn Service was held at Sydney’s Cenotaph during 1928. The simple ceremony was for veterans to assemble before dawn for ‘stand-to’ and two minutes of silence.

Hels said...

roentare

True!

When I started lecturing in history and art history in 1990, I assumed I was very well educated in British and British Empire history, as well as that of France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Russia and Israel. But soon became clear that I knew less about Australian history than necessary. Thank goodness for blogging.

Hels said...

Joe

I imagine that during the horrific Vietnam War of the late 1960s and early 1970s, the commitment to remembering war and honour was diminished across Australia. But once the school history curricula started to emphasise more of the Australian contribution to democracy and world stability, the Anzac legend thrived again. The ANZAC ceremonies now, in school assemblies or on-line, are taken very seriously.

Hels said...

David

thank you for the explanation. The Australian War Memorial wrote that their Dawn Service was a time to reflect in those quiet, peaceful moments before dawn. 2022's service was an informal standing ceremony. It included the laying of wreaths on behalf of Australia and New Zealand, symbolising the unity of ANZAC. From 4.30 am, representatives from the Australian Defence Force read excerpts from the letters and diaries of Australians who had experienced war first-hand.

DUTA said...

In March 2017, I visited ANZAC memorial in southern Israel, not far from the border with Gaza strip. I was very impressed, took some photos and wrote about the visit in a post entitled The Red South.

Andrew said...

It is interesting to compare ANZAC Day to Remembrance Day. People do think about the days quite differently. Remembrance Day feels very historical whereas ANZAC Day still quite relevant. I think now for many organisations, it is now a one minute silence on Remembrance Day, not two. I also think Remembrance Day will probably fade into history within a decade or so.

Hels said...

DUTA

I loved seeing the ANZAC memorial commemorating the Australian and N.Z soldiers who fell in battle in WW1. Many thanks

The most emotional part of Battle of Beersheba Commemoration for me was the service hosted by the Australian Ambassador and dignitaries at the Beersheba Commonwealth Cemet­ery. My son goes with every Australian, New Zealander and Brit he knows in Israel.
http://melbourneblogger.blogspot.com/2017/02/in-footsteps-of-anzacs-2017-tours-in.html

Hels said...

Andrew

I am beginning to agree with you.

Britain, France and the rest of the Allies valued Remembrance Day profoundly, especially as long as people personally remembered their fathers and grandfathers, and the stories they told.
Whereas Australians and New Zealanders of our grandchildren's generation seem to identify more personally with ANZAC Day, as you say. Perhaps we identify more with the nationalist importance of ANZAC Day, while British and French citizens do not.

Hels said...

Erika

I am guessing you didn't learn much about WW1 because Great Britain, France, Russia, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Serbia, Belgium etc sent their soldiers by train or ship as soon as war was declared in July 1914. The horrible impact on American families didn't start until mid 1917.

Happily there are wonderful WW1 blogs that your high school students would enjoy eg Mary Evans https://blog.maryevans.com/

Department Veterans' Affairs said...

During World War I, red poppies were among the first plants to grow on the Western Front in Europe. They bloomed across the wasted battlefields of northern France and Belgium. In Australia and other countries of the Commonwealth, we recognise the red poppy as the commemorative flower of remembrance. The flower still reminds us of those who lost their lives or suffered in wars, conflicts and peacekeeping operations.

The flower gave Canadian medic, Lieutenant-Colonel John McCrae, the inspiration for his poem, In Flanders Fields. McCrae wrote the poem while serving outside Ypres Belgium, in 1915.

Anzac Portal
Department Veterans' Affairs

Hels said...

Thank you. I can't believe that I didn't mention the poppies in my post since we always buy one to pin on the outside of the blouse.

But I didn't recognise the Frenchwoman Anna Guérin who first sold poppies in Britain in 1921, the Originator of Poppy Day. And although I remembered a few of the lines of In Flanders Fields, the name of Lieut-Col John McCrae had disappeared from my brain :(

Luiz Gomes said...

Boa Noite. Desejo um feliz ano novo e que em 2023 você possa realizar todos os seus sonhos e projetos.

Hels said...

Luiz

same to you.. a healthy and peaceful new year.

Now that no WW1 ex-sevicemen are alive, it is very important for us to read their personal histories, as well as official records.

diane b said...

My Grandfather was in the first world war. He was a gunner and went to India and Rangoon. When he returned home to London. His job was gone and he had lots of trouble trying to find work. Finally he worked as a porter on Fenchurch St Station.

Hels said...

diane

the time spent in the trenches etc was beyond awful, but I wonder if people took equal notice of what happened _after_ the young men came home. I know that the ex-servicemen could suffer a] mental pain (post traumatic stress disorders), b] physical wounds or c] intolerable changes at home (unemployment, divorce etc), largely ignored by their governments.

Like your grandpa, my grandfather survived and returned home, but it was terrible. He had only one functioning kidney :(

Hank Phillips said...

Thanks SOOOO much. I finally know where Comrade Orwell's Two Minutes' Hate came from. I'm listening to history lectures on the "Great" war. No mention that Serbia produced the strongest opium in the world, but all Balkan States were producers. Nor is there mention that Germany refined it into more heroin than the rest of the producers combined. The war miraculously occurred as ratification signatures accumulated on the Hague antiopium convention drafted to please Quing China. Those Armistice treaties fasten opium regulation rules all comers, forming a tighter cartel than before the war. The Second War was sparked by the League Narcotics Limitation Convention in June 1931, when German/Austrian banks collapsed. Yet all mention and attention is on the death and suffering of conscript slaves in the trenches... NOT on understanding the economic causes of both World Wars. See also LIBertrans.blogspot.com

Hels said...

Hank

I am not saying that economic causes of World War One were not important. But I was only interested in how nations, communities and families coped with life after the war ended and the servicemen came home well or wounded, or were buried in distant countries.

I don't think governments coped very well, by the way, so communities and families were left with an even worse burden. Hopefully the New Year will bring a brighter future.